Beat Box: Does Apple's iPad Have Any Value For Music Producers/Performers?
Thursday, January 28, 2010 at 12:04AM
Unless you haven’t left your house today (and do not own a TV or an Internet connection), you’ve probably heard about Apple’s unveiling of the iPad this afternoon. I’d have to say that for one of the company’s most widely speculated and, frankly, over-hyped product introductions in their entire 30-year history, it’s been interesting hearing the mixed reactions to the portable device over the course of the day.
Without getting too far into the specs and features of the iPad (which I’m sure have been drilled into your head by now), I feel that the summation of everyone’s reaction to it is that it merely seems like a large, overpriced version of the iPhone which still lacks Flash support, has no camera, but is optimized for reading electronic versions of newspapers and magazines. At $500, it’s price point will probably be a bit too expensive, especially for those who already use a netbook or iPhone.
What I find interesting is that if you turn back the clock on Apple’s history, there have almost always been mixed initial responses to product launches like this. When the first iPod was released in 2001, it’s $400 price tag scared a lot of potential users away. Many felt their money was much better justified buying a portable CD player or cheaper MP3 player with less storage space. Fast forward to 2007. The first iPhone was released for $500, and it came with restrictions on which service provider you could use. It took a long time for the iPhone and iPod to gain momentum. However, once the popularity rose as consumers ultimately found them to be useful within their daily lives, the price of both dropped and better versions were released.

It’s been interesting seeing the iPhone and iPod evolve, especially in the sense that both can do many more things then just what they were originally intended to do. Consumers had no clue that they would eventually be able to watch movies on an iPod in 2001, or download apps that could help them plan their next vacation on an iPhone in 2007. Practical features and additions to their initial feature sets have made both desirable for many years now.
I can see much of the same happening with the iPad, especially in the sense that it can carve itself several different niches in industries such as publishing and gaming. This actually lies in stark contrast to the iPhone/iPod, both of whom were walking blindfolded into over-saturated markets of PDA’s and MP3 players (respectively). There can possibly be some unchartered territory the iPad is jumping into; and as we all know, Apple has the knack for releasing products with features that “most consumers don’t even realize they want yet.”
Although I do not intend to purchase one myself, one niche that I especially see the iPad being useful in is for music production and performance.
Frankly, I think a 10” device has a great deal of potential in acting as a MIDI control surface. Jazzmutant’s Lemur has been a well received product which has such a feature set: a fully customizable midi interface, where you can build your own faders, knobs, trackpads, etc and assign them to any parameter within your DAW software. The problem is, few will be able to harness it’s usefulness because the $2000 price tag is outside most people’s price range. With Apple’s invitation for developers to hit the ground running with formulating iPad apps, if someone was to make a similar device to the Lemur run on this device, wouldn’t you think that would make it’s $500 seem like a good deal in comparison?

Software manufacturers such as Akai and Novation have recently jumped on the iPhone App bandwagon; and I find it interesting how both said companies released very popular physical control surfaces for Ableton Live last year. I can definitely see the potential in these guys making a control surface based app to control a program like Live via it’s interface. With an iPhone being a little too small to be practical, and a laptop possibly being too large and cumbersome, an iPad could be just the right size to trigger clips and ride faders, in an interface even more user-friendly than the Launchpad.
Remote editing of DAW’s through programs such as Hexer’s TouchOSC and the Cubase iPhone app is also feasible, although I think the iPhone holds an advantage in it’s size for now.
When thinking of the possibility of being able to launch apps that have different MIDI surfaces, all at your fingertips, instead of having to physically lug out three or four separate pieces of kit which do pretty much the same exact thing, this thing really starts to sound enticing.
Without a USB cable connection, I would probably have to write off the iPad’s potential of working with a DJ-based application such as Serato or Traktor for now. Because you’re dealing with more text when searching for songs, a small screen may be at a bit of a disadvantage. I’ve noticed that many who utilize Serato or Traktor prefer working off of 15” laptops and for good reason: it’s tough to see the tracklistings on a smaller screen! The iPhone DJ app can have some potential down the road if you want to keep things entirely within the box, however one significant thing I noticed about the iPad’s feature set is that it allegedly only outputs a mono signal. This would render monitoring under headphones useless as it would only work in one ear; however I might be wrong on this assumption so feel free to correct me!

Basically what I’m getting at here is that although the practical use of the iPad may not seem obvious at first, who knows what the future can hold for it. I’m not going to act like I can predict the future or anything, but the iPad does seem like quite an open-ended piece of hardware, and it should be interesting to see what developers will come up with and how the consumer market responds. After all, I said in the earlier part of the last decade that I would NEVER buy an iPod, and in the latter half that I have no use for an iPhone, and I don’t know how I lived without either for as long as I did! (PS- I also mentioned somewhere in this article that I wouldn’t plan on buying an iPad, either. I’ll be sure to remember this 3 or 4 years from now)
What are your thoughts on the iPad- do you think it has the potential to be of value to musicians and producers, or within your own profession for that matter? Or do you think it will be about as relevant as the Newton and G4 Cube by this time next year?









